The Breaker Times

There basically are two kinds of folks when it comes to smart TVs and how we use them to access all of our streaming services. There are those who just use whatever operating system is already built in, and those who prefer to plug in their own device.

That’s not to say there’s anything wrong with the former, especially since Roku, Amazon Fire TV, and Google TV power so many smart TVs, with LG and Samsung picking up the slack with their own operating systems.

But then there are those who prefer to have a little more control and who want to use some other stick or dongle or box to stream their videos — and maybe do a good bit more. And there’s something to be said about treating your TV like it’s a dumb display, especially if it’s an older model and doesn’t have all those smart things built into it. That’s where all these options come in.

And going with a separate device also gets you what we consider to be the “best” option. That’s subjective, of course, but we get paid to make tough choices. So here’s what we think are the best external streaming devices as of fall 2024. Some are newer than others. Some may be replaced in the months to come. All will serve you well.

But, yes, we do have a favorite.

Roku Streaming Stick 4K

The best of the inexpensive streaming devices

Jump to details

Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max

Also great, but for those who don’t want Roku

Jump to details

Google TV Streamer

The Chromecast replacement has some real smarts

Jump to details

Show 2 more items

Apple TV 4K (Late 2022)

The best overall streaming device

Two years is a fairly usual upgrade cycle for streaming devices, not that Apple particularly cares what anyone else is doing. So while it’s natural to look at the late-2022 Apple TV 4K and worry that it’s getting a little long in the tooth, fear not. This thing’s still as good as the day it was released.

Apple TV 4K still has the simplest, most consistent experience you can get, with a relatively open-ended shelf life. Those in the Apple ecosystem can make use of some of the extra features, it’s not just for those with iPhones and iPads. In the world of $50 streaming sticks that absolutely can get the job done and get it done fairly well, it’s perhaps a little hard to recommend something that costs three or four or five times as much. And to be clear, Apple TV 4K doesn’t do three or four or five times as much as its competitors. In fact, you can make the argument that it actually does a little less. More on that in a second. But what it does do, it tends to do better — and with fewer headaches.

What you get for that extra money is hardware that should darn near last forever. (Just ask anyone who’s still happily using the original Apple TV 4K, released in 2017.)

It’s tempting to say that the third-generation model is nearly identical to what was released with Gen 2 in 2021. And that’s mostly true, insofar as what the end user sees. The box itself is a little smaller, having gotten rid of the fan that you probably never heard anyway. And the internals have been spruced up, too. It’s now powered by the A15 Bionic processor, which provides plenty of headroom. And there’s now support for HDR 10+, which is important if you own a Samsung TV. (Samsung doesn’t support Dolby Vision.)

There also now are two models from which to choose. One has 32GB of storage and only uses Wi-Fi for connectivity. You do not want this model. Probably.

What you should really look at is the one that costs $20 more and includes Ethernet (of the super-fast Gigabit variety), as well as support for Thread and Matter. Those latter bits are new standards for smart-home connectivity, which allow devices to talk to each other directly. You might not care about that now, but it’s the future of smart home tech. Between that it having double the on-board storage capacity (and to be fair, 64GB is almost certainly too much, but nobody ever regretted having too much storage), this is the model you should consider.

And that’s all followed up by software updates that will span years in the future. The fourth-generation Apple TV — the last to top out at HD resolution and which is now referred to only as “Apple TV HD” — released in 2015 is still supported on tvOS. So there’s plenty of reason to believe that an Apple TV 4K purchased today should last at least five years, insofar as the software is concerned.

Apple’s tvOS is even more simple than its current phone and tablet software. The home screen is app icons, and that’s it. No real recommendations of shows or movies or live channels. No advertising. Nothing that overwhelms. That simplicity in and of itself may well be worth the extra money.

Those who are all-in with Apple’s ecosystem also will get the added bonus of things like AirPlay 2 and HomeKit — as well as ridiculously slick integration of using your iPhone or iPad for the on-screen keyboard. But even if you’re not, you’ll still be able to snag all the apps you could possibly need for your home viewing experience. And they’re all done in accordance with Apple’s developer standards, which are decidedly higher than other platforms on this list.

Apple TV 4K isn’t inexpensive. But it’s still the best.

Is an update coming soon? This model is nearly two years old going into late 2024, and it wouldn’t surprise us to see a new one in the coming year — (here are a few things we’d like to see in an update). But the late-2022 model will remain supported for years. If you want one now, buy one now.

Apple TV 4K (Late 2022)

The best overall streaming device

Nvidia Shield (2019)

The next-best streaming device

The best hardware that’s not Apple, plus a great option for gamers, the Shield (also often referred to as “Shield TV”) has a history dating back to 2015. That ancient hardware, running Nvidia’s Tegra X1 processor, was overpowered for the time and keeps that original box running just fine today.

The most recent Shield, released in 2019, comes in two flavors. Both add Dolby Vision into the mix, in addition to Dolby Atmos decoding. The non-Pro model comes in a cylindrical body for some reason. The Pro has more RAM and doubles the onboard storage to 16GB (both models still allow for external storage) and is meant for gaming via Nvidia’s G-Force Now system. And the Tegra X1+ processor is as good now as it was at release. Additionally, Nvidia does a great job at ensuring even more longevity to its devices with frequent updates that bring additional features and capabilities to the box.

Is a new one coming in 2024? Frankly, we have no idea. It’s amazing that Shield is still available, and even more amazing that it’s still as good as it is. That’s a testament to the hardware.

Nvidia Shield (2019)

The next-best streaming device

Roku Streaming Stick 4K

The best of the inexpensive streaming devices

Roku is the grandfather of streaming, back before it really became a thing. It remains as easy to use as ever, with “Channels” taking the place of apps. They’re really the same thing, and one Roku device works exactly the same as the next. It’s just a matter of what specs and features you get at what price.

The Streaming Stick 4K and its now discontinued sibling, the Streaming Stick 4K+, are identical, insofar as the sticks themselves go. You get 4K UHD resolution, support for Dolby Vision and Dolby Atmos, and improved Wi-Fi over previous models. The “Plus” side of the equation comes with the inclusion of the Roku Voice Remote Pro, which gives you hands-free voice control. Just say “Hey, Roku,” and the remote will hear you and execute your commands. It does so at a $20 premium ($50 and $70, respectively), which is worth it if that hands-free stuff and private listening via a headphone jack are important to you. You can still find the Plus version, just not through Roku itself. If you must have the Pro remote and can’t find the Streaming Stick 4K+, take a look at the Roku Ultra instead.

Roku’s operating system gets pretty regular updates, too, which usually brings some new features, interface updates, and access to new content. Here’s our explainer on how to update your Roku, just in case.

Roku has really started to stand out in the past couple of years with its inclusion of free shows and movies on its own distribution source, the aptly named The Roku Channel. The series and movies are all supported by advertising. There’s a lot of old content that you’ll recognize, as well as new original content. It also has dipped its toes into the realm of more standard original content with its own series, and presumably more is on the way.

Advertising-based content means more tracking, however, and that’s just something you have to keep in mind when it comes to Roku. But it’s hard to argue against the value proposition of the Streaming Stick 4K.

Is a new one coming in 2024? Given that the current model was released in September 2021, it wouldn’t surprise us in the slightest to see a new model in 2024. The only question is when.

Roku Streaming Stick 4K

The best of the inexpensive streaming devices

Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max

Also great, but for those who don’t want Roku

If Roku just isn’t your thing or you prefer the native Amazon and Alexa experience, a Fire TV stick might be the one for you. The original Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K has been a great buy for a couple of years now. Making it more “Max” just made it that much better, and it’s been updated as of September 2023. The Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max now has newer internals with a faster processor, Wi-Fi 6E, and continued support for Dolby Vision and Dolby Atmos. It ships with the latest Alexa Voice Remote, which doesn’t include hands-free voice access, but does have proper television controls.

What it doesn’t change is the same great experience you’ll get with Amazon Fire TV OS. While the home screen may still be a bit busy for some, that’s just a testament to how much great content is available in the Amazon ecosystem. Start with Amazon Prime Video, of course, which has all the movies and series you could possibly want, as well as more than its share of great original content.

And that’s all before you get to all the third-party streaming apps, games, and other options available on Amazon Fire TV. The Amazon Fire TV Stick remains an excellent choice and one that’s tough to beat.

The 2023 model of the Fire TV Stick 4K Max Max also is the first stick to have Amazon’s Ambient Experience (previously limited to its Omni series of televisions). You get a number of really good screensavers, or you can use your own photos as backgrounds for when you’re not actually watching TV. Plus, it has widgets of varying degrees of usefulness.

Any real complaints we have here tend to be in performance. This is still a low-cost device, and laggy graphics and load times occasionally remind us of that fact.

Is a new one coming in 2024? This version was released in the fall of 2023 and is unlikely to be updated anytime soon. But Amazon may well update the Fire TV Cube, which has different features and is more expensive.

Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max

Also great, but for those who don’t want Roku

Google TV Streamer

The Chromecast replacement has some real smarts

The Google TV Streamer takes everything that was great about Chromecast with Google TV — mainly the stock experience and direct love from Google itself — fixes what needed fixing, and adds what needed to be added. It fully replaces Chromecast in the Google ecosystem.

The basic experience isn’t really much different than Chromecast with Google TV. You get the same busy homescreen and all the same apps.

But new this time around is an improved remote control that’s easier to hold and easier to use, with a lost-remote finder built in, so you can make it chirp when it goes missing. While the base itself can no longer be hidden behind a television, it’s not meant to be because of the addition of a bunch of smart home tech.

The Google TV Streamer supports the Thread and Matter standards, which help all your smart devices talk to each other and work in a single ecosystem. And the Google TV OS has been updated so you can view cameras and adjust lights and temperature using your TV remote.

Welcome to the future.

Google TV Streamer

The Chromecast replacement has some real smarts

Frequently Asked Questions